Products · Pattern or everyday thing
Dvorak keyboard layout
Raised as a usability problem by 85 people on Hacker News over 18 years (2008–2025), in 49 threads.
No issue was raised by at least 3 people in 3 threads this year.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
Every issue, all time, most people first
Typing on QWERTY keyboards becomes slow, needing constant layout switchingUnreviewed
20082026- Apps' default keybindings are poorly suited to Dvorak, forcing users to customize each app2025-09-02
- Dvorak skill is muscle memory, so the user can't read the layout on a phone2023-06-07
- Dvorak is awkward for one-handed typing on touch screens, since keys alternate hands poorly2023-06-07
Switching layouts means reconfiguring editors and hard shortcutsUnreviewed
20082026- Keyboard shortcuts must be relearned and are in worse locations, like Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V2025-09-02
- Keyboard shortcuts break when switching to a different layout, making it hard to use2024-09-03
- Shortcuts clash with layout, so users must stop and think which layout they are using2023-05-19
Shortcuts and game prompts assume QWERTY, causing wrong pressesUnreviewed
20082026- Game bindings follow physical key positions, so the commenter can't tell where the keys are2025-09-02
- Game key prompts mismatch Dvorak letter positions, causing frequent mistyping of button prompts2023-06-07
- Couldn't switch back to QWERTY on other computers; struggled to locate keys2023-05-19
Typing speed drops sharply in the first daysUnreviewed
20082026- Typing speed drops sharply in the first days, making it frustrating to keep using2023-06-07
- Takes months of retraining muscle memory, slowing typing for years after switching2023-06-07
- Typing by conscious finger placement is slow and distracting for weeks while learning2018-09-20
Keeps typing shortcuts and punctuation wrongUnreviewed
20082026- Copy and paste shortcuts end up scattered across the keyboard instead of clustered together2017-02-01
- Keeps getting shortcuts and punctuation wrong; shortcut keys are awkward on the left hand2009-01-08
- Existing keyboard shortcuts in apps like Firefox and GMail are hard to relearn2008-03-02
Right pinky overloaded with more keystrokes than other fingersUnreviewed
20082026- Puts too much load on pinky fingers, and German typing is awkward2020-06-04
- Right pinky finger overloaded, performing more keystrokes than other fingers2017-02-01
- Pinky finger strain from having to reach symbol and modifier keys on QWERTY2014-06-01
Layout must be reset each time, and boot passphrase typed wronglyUnreviewed
20082026- Custom layout can't be default; macOS lock screen refuses it for password entry2023-06-07
- Keyboard layout switches before login, so passwords must be memorised in two layouts2018-09-20
- Must set up the layout again every time, and disk passphrase typed in wrong layout at boot2017-10-03
Brackets are poorly placed, making code symbols harder to typeUnreviewed
20082026- Braces and brackets sit too far from the home row, making programming hard to type2021-04-13
- Brackets are poorly placed for programming, making code symbols harder to type2020-06-04
- Bracket keys are awkwardly placed, so programmers miss them more often2013-12-27
Unreviewed issues were grouped by machine: Claude Haiku labelled each comment as a usability complaint, named what it's about and summed up the problem in a line, and a small model grouped similar problems. Nobody has checked them by hand. Expect mistakes.
The newest 50 complaints
- Apps' default keybindings are poorly suited to Dvorak, forcing users to customize each app2025-09-02
- Keyboard shortcuts must be relearned and are in worse locations, like Ctrl+C and Ctrl+V2025-09-02
- Game bindings follow physical key positions, so the commenter can't tell where the keys are2025-09-02
- Keyboard shortcuts break when switching to a different layout, making it hard to use2024-09-03
- Dvorak skill is muscle memory, so the user can't read the layout on a phone2023-06-07
- Dvorak is awkward for one-handed typing on touch screens, since keys alternate hands poorly2023-06-07
- Game key prompts mismatch Dvorak letter positions, causing frequent mistyping of button prompts2023-06-07
- Dvorak shortcuts clash with QWERTY ones; Windows mapping programs are buggy and Linux setup is messy2023-06-07
- Typing speed drops sharply in the first days, making it frustrating to keep using2023-06-07
- Takes months of retraining muscle memory, slowing typing for years after switching2023-06-07
- Switching between Dvorak and QWERTY machines makes typing slow and requires re-learning key positions2023-06-07
- Hotkeys are a mess and often positioned for QWERTY, not Dvorak2023-06-07
- Custom layout can't be default; macOS lock screen refuses it for password entry2023-06-07
- Vowels are placed on the same side, causing collisions that make typing hard2023-06-07
- Couldn't switch back to QWERTY on other computers; struggled to locate keys2023-05-19
- Shortcuts clash with layout, so users must stop and think which layout they are using2023-05-19
- Underscore and parentheses keys are hard to reach, causing RSI pain2023-01-25
- After learning Dvorak, typing on others' QWERTY keyboards becomes slow and requires constant layout switching2023-01-01
- Dvorak layout is nearly unusable with swipe typing2022-10-10
- Right-hand-heavy layout requires excessive finger travel, hurting ergonomics for left-handed typists2022-07-23
- After learning Dvorak, can't type on other computers without hunting for every key2022-03-18
- Games and programs using WASD or hjkl keys clash with Dvorak layout, forcing a switch back2022-03-18
- Shortcuts like Command-N don't work in some apps, forcing the physical key position of a different letter2022-03-18
- Dvorak layout is awkward on phones, tiring fingers when typing one-handed2022-02-07
- Dvorak muscle memory does not transfer to touchscreen keyboard; lacks glide typing2022-01-22
- Switching layouts was horrible for the first two months of typing2022-01-21
- Cmd+C and Cmd+V are hard to reach on the Dvorak layout2022-01-06
- Shortcuts and game prompts assume QWERTY, causing wrong key presses2022-01-06
- Layout switcher's Ctrl+Shift shortcut silently swaps layouts, producing wrong letters and failed logins2022-01-06
- Switching layouts causes long-lasting errors and drops typing ability for weeks or months2021-11-30
- Keys A and M confused the learner and reverted to QWERTY habits frustratingly2021-04-13
- Shortcut positions move, so pressing the wrong key can close the window instead2021-04-13
- Hotkeys break or conflict when remapping keys across software layers2021-04-13
- Dvorak overloads the right pinky finger, causing discomfort when touch typing2021-04-13
- Braces and brackets sit too far from the home row, making programming hard to type2021-04-13
- Switching layouts causes productivity loss, slow relearning, and interference with QWERTY typing2021-04-13
- Family members can't tell how to switch the computer back from Dvorak mode2020-08-12
- Puts too much load on pinky fingers, and German typing is awkward2020-06-04
- Brackets are poorly placed for programming, making code symbols harder to type2020-06-04
- Relearning typing on the layout is painful and slows typing for weeks2020-06-04
- After using Dvorak, QWERTY keyboards everywhere became very hard to use2019-02-17
- Apps crash on launch and lack basic usability features like double-space period2018-09-21
- Typing by conscious finger placement is slow and distracting for weeks while learning2018-09-20
- Dvorak layout makes typing on others' computers frustrating and slow, requiring hunting for keys2018-09-20
- Muscle memory mismatch makes typing feel painful and error-prone during learning2018-09-20
- Keyboard layout switches before login, so passwords must be memorised in two layouts2018-09-20
- Switching layouts on other people's machines is hard, so typing drops back to QWERTY habits2018-09-20
- Takes minutes to readapt, causing random caps and mistyped letters2018-09-20
- Dvorak layout is a hassle when other people must use the same computer2018-09-20
- Some hotkeys can't be reached while right hand is on the mouse2018-08-27