Products · Pattern or everyday thing
Magic link logins
Raised as a usability problem by 12 people on Hacker News over 10 years (2017–2026), in 10 threads.
No issue was raised by at least 3 people in 3 threads this year.
Every issue, all time, most people first
Magic link login fails when email isn't set up on deviceUnreviewed
20172026- Magic link opens in wrong browser session, forcing an extra manual step to reach signed-in page2026-04-15
- Password manager can't autofill magic link logins, causing friction2025-11-17
- Magic link must be opened in the same browser that requested it, otherwise login fails2025-01-08
Login link emails clutter the inbox and distractUnreviewed
20172026- Login links clutter the inbox and distract when trying to log in2025-01-07
- Link opens in mail app's own browser, forcing re-login after switching back2021-11-02
- Having to open email inbox every time to log in is tedious2017-10-29
Unreviewed issues were grouped by machine: Claude Haiku labelled each comment as a usability complaint, named what it's about and summed up the problem in a line, and a small model grouped similar problems. Nobody has checked them by hand. Expect mistakes.
The newest 12 complaints
- Magic link opens in wrong browser session, forcing an extra manual step to reach signed-in page2026-04-15
- Password manager can't autofill magic link logins, causing friction2025-11-17
- Links are hard to read and fail when logging in on a different device2025-01-24
- Magic link must be opened in the same browser that requested it, otherwise login fails2025-01-08
- Login links clutter the inbox and distract when trying to log in2025-01-07
- Password manager autofill fails because email-first login slides in fields slowly, and magic links force opening email2024-07-04
- Must transfer the emailed magic link between devices, which is awkward when email isn't set up on all devices2022-05-21
- Switching to email for the magic link distracts users, who forget they are logging in2022-05-11
- Users must wait 15+ minutes to complete certain actions2021-11-07
- Link opens in mail app's own browser, forcing re-login after switching back2021-11-02
- Magic link login is terrible when email isn't set up on the device being used2021-08-20
- Having to open email inbox every time to log in is tedious2017-10-29