Products · Product
Microsoft account
Raised as a usability problem by 177 people on Hacker News over 15 years (2012–2026), in 112 threads.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
Every issue, all time, most people first
Users get locked out of accounts and can't easily recover themUnreviewed
20122026- Clients permanently locked out of accounts due to outdated or insufficient recovery information2026-06-15
- Account gets locked after failed logins and asks for a reset even with a working password2026-05-24
- Gets locked out of accounts and can't easily recover them2025-08-16
Skype account became inaccessible after the account mergeUnreviewed
20122026- Legacy Skype and Hotmail accounts were locked out after the merge, so users couldn't log in2026-03-28
- Skype keeps swapping the logged-in user with the linked Xbox account2024-11-20
- Old MSN account unusable for Skype and Xbox, stuck between auth migrations2024-08-23
Captchas so hard it took five minutes and still failedUnreviewed
20122026- Account creation requires many fields, then a press-and-hold captcha that loops on 'please try again'2026-08-04
- Captchas so difficult it took five minutes and still failed2025-01-03
- CAPTCHAs are so hard to pass that the user gave up on them2023-05-29
Accounts sharing an email but different passwords confuse loginsUnreviewed
20122026- Same email ends up with two accounts; work 2FA hijacks personal login2023-02-25
- Multiple unsynced accounts cause confusion, and password reset or recovery is a constant hassle2022-02-18
- Many confusing overlapping accounts; some logins work, others don't, unclear which to use2022-02-09
Buying the game through a Microsoft account is hardUnreviewed
20122026- Buying a game requires endless logins, captchas, verifications and redirects between sites2026-08-04
- Buying the game through Microsoft account is weirdly hard2023-09-15
- Logging into a game forces the whole Windows PC to sign into the same Microsoft account2023-02-25
Endless login prompts train users to enter credentials carelesslyUnreviewed
20122026- Password prompts pop up unexpectedly, making real and phishing prompts hard to tell apart2025-02-15
- Endless login prompts and authenticator warnings train users to enter credentials carelessly2024-07-17
- Frequent authentication popups require far too much manual intervention2024-03-18
Disabled email and SMS MFA methods keep being re-enabled by policyUnreviewed
20122026- Disabled email and SMS MFA methods keep getting re-enabled by an admin policy2025-08-07
- Repeatedly asked to re-login on home computer, MFA device often out of reach2024-12-17
- Users can't individually opt into stronger MFA; secure options are hidden and disabled by default2022-02-16
Nothing indicates the user needs to sign inUnreviewed
20122026- Users must click back after the login screen to create an account without signing in2024-02-26
- Sign-in is confusing for users and easy for developers to get wrong2023-02-25
- Nothing indicates the user needs to sign in2013-02-28
Can't manage 2FA or choose which account to log in withUnreviewed
20122026- Can't manage 2FA or choose which account to log in with2023-02-25
- Repeated 'Temporary problem' errors when trying to log in with 2FA and SSO2021-10-12
- Must log back in with 2FA every Monday due to short cache lifetime2019-09-08
Dark patterns push users into signing in with a Microsoft accountUnreviewed
20122026- Users are pushed by a dark pattern into a new login standard they did not choose2024-12-17
- Dark patterns push users into signing in with a Microsoft account against their choice2021-06-29
- Dark patterns push users to feel they need a Microsoft account to use their own computer2018-07-28
Can't tell which account is logged in, causing wrong-account loginsUnreviewed
20122026- Can't tell which account is logged in; sign-in windows hidden and unexplained, leading to wrong-account logins2021-09-09
- Account sign-in flow confuses which account the user is logging into2019-09-10
- Hidden account-type redirect makes the login process confusing and unclear to users2019-06-28
Unreviewed issues were grouped by machine: Claude Haiku labelled each comment as a usability complaint, named what it's about and summed up the problem in a line, and a small model grouped similar problems. Nobody has checked them by hand. Expect mistakes.
The newest 50 complaints
- Login pages have broken redirects, broken links and buttons that loop back2026-10-19
- Login hides the password option until passkey attempts fail twice2026-09-18
- Hours spent figuring out which account system handles parental controls; search pointed to the wrong site2026-08-05
- Buying a game requires endless logins, captchas, verifications and redirects between sites2026-08-04
- Account creation requires many fields, then a press-and-hold captcha that loops on 'please try again'2026-08-04
- Login loops back to sign-in screen after password entry, blocking access for 30 minutes2026-08-04
- Login bounces through many redirects that fail often; settings scattered across systems2026-07-27
- Verification link expired, forcing support contact and many messages2026-07-14
- Clients permanently locked out of accounts due to outdated or insufficient recovery information2026-06-15
- Switching between two organisations' accounts requires deleting all Microsoft cookies2026-06-08
- Can't see where failed login attempts come from or whether any succeeded2026-06-02
- Account gets locked after failed logins and asks for a reset even with a working password2026-05-24
- Choosing alternative sign-in methods leads to password reset, locking user out2026-05-22
- Sign-in gets stuck in a loop, forcing repeated credential and 2FA entry2026-04-03
- Can't find a setting to switch emails to English2026-04-03
- Legacy Skype and Hotmail accounts were locked out after the merge, so users couldn't log in2026-03-28
- Migrating to a new PC is painful because apps and settings don't transfer2026-03-27
- Users can't tell which org login to use and get stuck when signing out2026-03-27
- Login and purchase for a small Minecraft buy required dozens of steps and ended at fraud department2026-03-18
- Can't switch from one account to another without clearing all cookies, else permission denied errors2026-03-18
- Permissions site is so confusingly laid out that user still felt lost after three tries2026-03-18
- Login requires repeated verifications, codes and resets; purchases denied with vague error2026-02-20
- Custom user fields are invisible in the UI, reachable only via API; provisioning clunky and slow2025-08-19
- "Don't ask me next time" checkbox keeps prompting on every login, so the choice doesn't stick2025-08-17
- Gets locked out of accounts and can't easily recover them2025-08-16
- Disabled email and SMS MFA methods keep getting re-enabled by an admin policy2025-08-07
- UX creates an impossible flow that locks users out of their accounts2025-07-31
- Users lose access to their PC login when they lose the 2FA method, with no password-free option2025-06-10
- Has to re-enter a password for each tool despite already being logged into the desktop session2025-05-24
- Password prompts pop up unexpectedly, making real and phishing prompts hard to tell apart2025-02-15
- Captchas so difficult it took five minutes and still failed2025-01-03
- Repeatedly asked to re-login on home computer, MFA device often out of reach2024-12-17
- Users cannot permanently opt out and get nagged with pushy notifications2024-12-17
- Confusing passkey flow leaves users with unbacked-up passkeys and locked out2024-12-17
- Users are pushed by a dark pattern into a new login standard they did not choose2024-12-17
- Must remember which domain to use; password saved for one domain goes stale on the other2024-12-03
- Skype keeps swapping the logged-in user with the linked Xbox account2024-11-20
- Deletion blocked by a 'known issues' popup; support unreachable and ticket bounced around for a month2024-11-16
- Sign-up has flaws, one apparently fatal, requiring a lot of work to get around2024-11-14
- Signing in to email redirects across five different domains, taking about ten seconds2024-09-02
- Old MSN account unusable for Skype and Xbox, stuck between auth migrations2024-08-23
- Endless login prompts and authenticator warnings train users to enter credentials carelessly2024-07-17
- Dumbphone users can't access Microsoft services without an authentication app on a smartphone2024-07-11
- Frequent authentication popups require far too much manual intervention2024-03-18
- Users must click back after the login screen to create an account without signing in2024-02-26
- Must click through extra steps to pick a security key; default sign-in keeps forcing Windows Hello2024-02-20
- Skype app shows a false 'couldn't log in' error despite being logged in2024-02-18
- Server rejects tokens with opaque errors, giving no explanation of what went wrong2024-01-19
- Remember-me never worked, so it sent about 50 2FA texts a day2023-12-05
- Gets signed out constantly and login fails with errors until browser is restarted2023-12-02