HackerFriction Feedback

Gmail · Reviewed

Interface is slow to use, so everyday tasks wait

Raised by 292 people over 19 years (2008–2026), in 19 of them.

What people report

  • the new ui they've done is slow and bloated, and seems to have little improvements
    Read the comment ↗
  • I don't use gmail because of crappy ui, ux and designs.
    Read the comment ↗
  • the immediately previous incarnation of Gmail looked less cluttered and felt snappier
    Read the comment ↗
  • Gmail, the website, takes at least 2 minutes to load and be usable, so much that I need to use a separate extension
    Read the comment ↗
  • What used to be instantaneous (like, opening an email) now takes seconds.
    Read the comment ↗

Principle

Response time limits (Nielsen's 0.1/1/10 seconds)

People report that Gmail, especially since the redesign, takes long to load and feels sluggish to respond, and that scrolling can jump back to the top. This pushes routine reading and writing past the delays where users stay in flow, and some say they consider leaving.

A fix

Set and enforce performance budgets for first load and common actions (open message, compose, scroll), and render the inbox list before secondary panels and add-ons load. Keep a working lightweight mode that the Basic HTML link actually switches to, and preserve scroll position on mobile browsers.

Grouping, principle and fix drafted with Claude and reviewed by Justusability. Counts are people whose comment Claude labelled a usability complaint about this issue; see Method for how, and its limits. Something wrong here?

All 319 source comments
  1. 2008-05-24
  2. 2009-04-08
  3. 2009-07-04
  4. 2009-10-19
  5. 2010-01-28
  6. 2010-04-09
  7. 2010-05-28
  8. 2010-05-28
  9. 2010-06-04
  10. 2010-06-26
  11. 2010-07-09
  12. 2010-10-05
  13. 2010-11-05
  14. 2010-11-05
  15. 2010-11-06
  16. 2011-04-07
  17. 2011-06-21
  18. 2011-08-31
  19. 2011-10-12
  20. 2011-11-02
  21. 2011-11-02
  22. 2011-11-02
  23. 2011-11-03
  24. 2011-11-16
  25. 2011-12-26
  26. 2012-02-22
  27. 2012-04-19
  28. 2012-04-26
  29. 2012-06-03
  30. 2012-08-01
  31. 2012-08-30
  32. 2012-09-05
  33. 2012-09-10
  34. 2012-10-30
  35. 2012-12-06
  36. 2013-02-04
  37. 2013-02-04
  38. 2013-02-13
  39. 2013-03-15
  40. 2013-03-16
  41. 2013-03-21
  42. 2013-03-28
  43. 2013-05-03
  44. 2013-05-03
  45. 2013-07-15
  46. 2013-09-04
  47. 2013-09-07
  48. 2013-09-23
  49. 2013-11-06
  50. 2013-11-18
  51. 2013-11-26
  52. 2013-12-11
  53. 2013-12-13
  54. 2014-02-03
  55. 2014-02-21
  56. 2014-02-21
  57. 2014-02-25
  58. 2014-03-19
  59. 2014-03-19
  60. 2014-04-11
  61. 2014-11-04
  62. 2014-11-16
  63. 2014-11-20
  64. 2014-12-20
  65. 2015-02-06
  66. 2015-02-10
  67. 2015-04-20
  68. 2015-05-11
  69. 2015-05-16
  70. 2015-06-01
  71. 2015-11-10
  72. 2015-11-11
  73. 2016-01-11
  74. 2016-02-18
  75. 2016-06-03
  76. 2016-08-16
  77. 2016-09-28
  78. 2017-02-09
  79. 2017-03-10
  80. 2017-05-07
  81. 2017-05-09
  82. 2017-06-11
  83. 2017-06-19
  84. 2017-06-23
  85. 2017-08-06
  86. 2017-09-20
  87. 2017-10-24
  88. 2017-12-18
  89. 2018-04-12
  90. 2018-04-25
  91. 2018-04-29
  92. 2018-07-26
  93. 2018-08-24
  94. 2018-08-25
  95. 2018-09-12
  96. 2018-09-12
  97. 2018-09-12
  98. 2018-09-13
  99. 2018-09-16
  100. 2018-09-16
  101. 2018-09-23
  102. 2018-09-24
  103. 2018-09-24
  104. 2018-09-25
  105. 2018-09-27
  106. 2018-09-27
  107. 2018-09-28
  108. 2018-09-28
  109. 2018-09-28
  110. 2018-09-28
  111. 2018-09-28
  112. 2018-09-28
  113. 2018-09-28
  114. 2018-09-28
  115. 2018-09-28
  116. 2018-09-28
  117. 2018-09-28
  118. 2018-09-28
  119. 2018-09-28
  120. 2018-09-28
  121. 2018-09-29
  122. 2018-09-29
  123. 2018-09-30
  124. 2018-09-30
  125. 2018-09-30
  126. 2018-09-30
  127. 2018-09-30
  128. 2018-09-30
  129. 2018-09-30
  130. 2018-09-30
  131. 2018-09-30
  132. 2018-09-30
  133. 2018-09-30
  134. 2018-10-01
  135. 2018-10-02
  136. 2018-10-03
  137. 2018-10-04
  138. 2018-10-07
  139. 2018-10-08
  140. 2018-10-09
  141. 2018-10-15
  142. 2018-10-23
  143. 2018-10-23
  144. 2018-10-23
  145. 2018-10-26
  146. 2018-10-26
  147. 2018-10-26
  148. 2018-10-28
  149. 2018-10-31
  150. 2018-10-31
  151. 2018-11-05
  152. 2018-11-05
  153. 2018-11-05
  154. 2018-11-05
  155. 2018-11-05
  156. 2018-11-05
  157. 2018-11-05
  158. 2018-11-05
  159. 2018-11-05
  160. 2018-11-05
  161. 2018-11-05
  162. 2018-11-05
  163. 2018-11-05
  164. 2018-11-05
  165. 2018-11-07
  166. 2018-11-13
  167. 2018-11-17
  168. 2018-11-17
  169. 2018-11-17
  170. 2018-11-17
  171. 2018-11-17
  172. 2018-11-17
  173. 2018-11-22
  174. 2018-11-22
  175. 2018-12-04
  176. 2018-12-08
  177. 2019-01-13
  178. 2019-01-22
  179. 2019-01-22
  180. 2019-01-25
  181. 2019-02-04
  182. 2019-02-13
  183. 2019-02-17
  184. 2019-02-18
  185. 2019-02-24
  186. 2019-03-02
  187. 2019-03-13
  188. 2019-03-20
  189. 2019-03-27
  190. 2019-04-04
  191. 2019-04-07
  192. 2019-04-15
  193. 2019-04-15
  194. 2019-04-20
  195. 2019-04-24
  196. 2019-04-24
  197. 2019-04-26
  198. 2019-04-26
  199. 2019-04-26
  200. 2019-05-22
  201. 2019-05-28
  202. 2019-05-30
  203. 2019-06-27
  204. 2019-06-28
  205. 2019-07-24
  206. 2019-07-24
  207. 2019-07-24
  208. 2019-07-24
  209. 2019-07-25
  210. 2019-07-25
  211. 2019-08-21
  212. 2019-08-21
  213. 2019-08-30
  214. 2019-11-03
  215. 2019-11-11
  216. 2019-11-11
  217. 2019-11-21
  218. 2019-11-21
  219. 2019-12-11
  220. 2019-12-12
  221. 2019-12-17
  222. 2019-12-19
  223. 2020-01-01
  224. 2020-01-24
  225. 2020-01-24
  226. 2020-01-24
  227. 2020-02-26
  228. 2020-03-08
  229. 2020-03-08
  230. 2020-03-09
  231. 2020-03-09
  232. 2020-04-11
  233. 2020-04-12
  234. 2020-04-16
  235. 2020-04-16
  236. 2020-04-27
  237. 2020-05-08
  238. 2020-05-08
  239. 2020-05-15
  240. 2020-05-16
  241. 2020-06-06
  242. 2020-06-23
  243. 2020-06-24
  244. 2020-07-17
  245. 2020-07-18
  246. 2020-07-22
  247. 2020-08-05
  248. 2020-08-22
  249. 2020-09-09
  250. 2020-09-09
  251. 2020-09-25
  252. 2020-09-25
  253. 2020-11-12
  254. 2020-11-18
  255. 2020-12-09
  256. 2020-12-14
  257. 2020-12-14
  258. 2021-01-13
  259. 2021-02-08
  260. 2021-02-08
  261. 2021-04-14
  262. 2021-04-29
  263. 2021-05-18
  264. 2021-06-22
  265. 2021-07-07
  266. 2021-08-20
  267. 2021-11-11
  268. 2021-11-11
  269. 2021-12-24
  270. 2022-01-19
  271. 2022-01-19
  272. 2022-01-20
  273. 2022-01-24
  274. 2022-02-06
  275. 2022-02-17
  276. 2022-02-17
  277. 2022-03-02
  278. 2022-03-14
  279. 2022-03-31
  280. 2022-06-07
  281. 2022-06-07
  282. 2022-06-27
  283. 2022-08-24
  284. 2022-10-24
  285. 2022-12-04
  286. 2022-12-10
  287. 2023-04-26
  288. 2023-04-29
  289. 2023-05-02
  290. 2023-05-28
  291. 2023-09-24
  292. 2023-09-24
  293. 2023-10-23
  294. 2023-10-23
  295. 2023-11-02
  296. 2023-11-17
  297. 2023-12-08
  298. 2024-01-17
  299. 2024-03-12
  300. 2024-03-30
  301. 2024-05-29
  302. 2024-06-20
  303. 2024-10-08
  304. 2024-11-19
  305. 2025-03-05
  306. 2025-03-10
  307. 2025-04-03
  308. 2025-04-24
  309. 2025-05-10
  310. 2025-11-07
  311. 2025-11-09
  312. 2026-01-24
  313. 2026-02-21
  314. 2026-04-08
  315. 2026-05-30
  316. 2026-06-02
  317. 2026-06-03
  318. 2026-06-03
  319. 2026-06-10